What if airlines could win more passengers and increase revenue without upgrading the seat? New research from EPIC suggests that the business-class experience on the ground could be a powerful competitive advantage, particularly on short-haul routes where time spent at the airport rivals time in the air.
Using the New York–Chicago market as a case study, EPIC examined how adding lounge access, priority security, and priority boarding to economy and extra-legroom fares could influence passenger choices and airline revenue.
The findings reveal a compelling opportunity. When United Airlines introduced these hypothetical enhanced fares, its simulated market share increased from 30.6% to 35.6%, while route revenue rose by 9.1%. The new fares captured 16.4% of passenger choices, attracting travelers from competitors and encouraging existing customers to upgrade.
However, the opportunity comes with important trade-offs. Travelers without existing lounge access valued the additional benefits significantly more than those already enjoying them through credit cards or frequent-flyer status. Leisure passengers also demonstrated greater potential than business travelers.
Crucially, the revenue gains depended on attracting customers from competing airlines, rather than simply shifting existing passengers between fare categories. Aircraft capacity, lounge congestion, and the potential erosion of premium benefits all present commercial challenges.
The study highlights a broader strategic question for airlines: Can a carefully targeted premium ground experience become a profitable differentiator in an increasingly competitive market?
The answer may depend less on what airlines offer and more on whom they offer it to.